| Tuesday, Sept. 1 | MARIAN | Richmond, Indiana | W, 2-0 |
| Saturday, Sept. 5 | at Goshen | Goshen, Indiana | L, 2-3 (ot) |
| Wednesday, Sept. 9 | WILMINGTON | Richmond, Indiana | T, 1-1 (ot) |
| Saturday, Sept. 12 | at Anderson | Anderson, Indiana | W, 2-1 |
| Sunday, Sept. 13 | at Wabash | Crawfordsville, Indiana | W, 1-0 |
| Wednesday, Sept. 16 | at Rose-Hulman | Terre Haute, Indiana | W, 4-0 |
| Saturday, Sept. 19 | HANOVER | Richmond, Indiana | W, 7-0 |
| Saturday, Sept. 26 | *WOOSTER | Richmond, Indiana | W, 4-0 |
| Wednesday, Sept. 30 | at DePauw | Greencastle, Indiana | T, 0-0 (ot) |
| Saturday, Oct. 3 | *DENISON | Richmond, Indiana | L, 0-1 |
| Tuesday, Oct. 6 | TAYLOR | Richmond, Indiana | W, 1-0 |
| Saturday, Oct. 10 | *at Case Western Reserve | Cleveland, Ohio | W, 4-0 |
| Tuesday, Oct. 13 | *WITTENBERG | Richmond, Indiana | W, 1-0 (ot) |
| Saturday, Oct. 17 | *at Ohio Wesleyan | Delaware, Ohio | L, 0-1 |
| Thursday, Oct. 22 | ST. FRANCIS | Richmond, Indiana | W, 3-0 |
| Saturday, Oct. 24 | *ALLEGHENY | Richmond, Indiana | W, 2-0 |
| Wednesday, Oct. 28 | MANCHESTER | Richmond, Indiana | W, 2-1 (ot) |
| Saturday, Oct. 31 | *at Oberlin | Oberlin, Ohio | W, 3-1 |
| Saturday, Nov. 7 | *at Kenyon | Gambier, Ohio | L, 0-1 |
| Wednesday, Nov. 11 | OTTERBEIN (NCAA Division III Great Lakes Regional First Round) | Richmond, Indiana | L, 0-1 |