| No. | Name | Pos. | Yr. | Hometown | High School | Club Team |
| 1 | Bryan Wallace | G | So. | Pataskala, OH | Watkins Memorial | Xtabi |
| 2 | Sam Byrd | M | Fr. | Richmond, IN | Richmond | Richmond FC |
| 3 | David Keyes | M | So. | Yellow Springs, OH | Yellow Springs | Dayton United |
| 4 | Chris Wilson** | F | Jr. | Cambridge, VT | Mt. Mansfield Union | Chittenden United |
| 5 | Luke Bigelow | B | So. | Evanston, IL | Evanston Township | Team Evanston |
| 6 | Marc Sampson | B | Fr. | Centerville, OH | Centerville | Team Dayton |
| 7 | Ryan Guess | M | Fr. | Columbus, IN | East | South Central Select |
| 8 | Chris Lindsey***+ | B | Sr. | Indianapolis, IN | Pike | Indy Inferno |
| 9 | Andrew Sampson***+ | B | Sr. | Centerville, OH | Centerville | Team Dayton |
| 10 | Ricky Huntley* | M | So. | Cinncinati, OH | Cincinnati Country Day | Cincinnati United Premier |
| 11 | Walter Antoniuk** | B | Sr. | Philadelphia, PA | Central | Flame |
| 12 | Michael Mele | F | Fr. | Greensburg, PA | Sewickley Academy | Penns Forest |
| 13 | Manton Hurd | M | Sr. | Berkeley, CA | Proctor Academy, NH | |
| 14 | Gerald George | M | Fr. | Greencastle, IN | Greencastle | Dynamo FC |
| 15 | Bergis Jules | F | Fr. | Richmond, IN | Richmond | |
| 16 | Matt Cirbo* | M | So. | Longmont, CO | Niwot | St. Vrain Express |
| 17 | Ian Horn* | M | So. | Midway, KY | Woodford County | Bonair |
| 18 | Jamie Dick***+ | F | Sr. | Middletown, OH | Middletown | Team Cincinnati |
| 19 | Nathan Cline | B | Fr. | Columbus, IN | East | South Central Select |
| 20 | Andrew Williams** | F | Jr. | Fort Wayne, IN | South Side | |
| 21 | Imants Jaunarajs** | M | Jr. | Lakewood, CO | Bear Creek | Lakewood Fury |
| 22 | Damon Buster** | B | Jr. | Yellow Springs, OH | Yellow Springs | Dayton Spirit |
| 23 | Kyle Grady* | B | So. | West Chester, OH | Lakota | Cincinnati United Premier |
| 24 | James Carrico | G | So. | Williamstown, MA | Buxton School | |
| ---- | Jacob Blickenov | B | Fr. | Cincinnati, OH | Creative & Performing Arts | |
| ---- | Michael Brown-Hayes | B | So. | West Chester, PA | Westtown | Burlington FC |
| ---- | Stephen Chidester | B | Fr. | Richmond, IN | Westtown, PA |
Head Coach: Roy Messer (Wooster ‘70), 19th year
Assistant Coach: Marc Colwell (Indiana ‘95), second year
* denotes letters earned
+ denotes captains
9/2/99