"Stealth" Applications
Increase Enrollment Pools,
Decrease Yield Rates
For Immediate Release:
Jan. 8, 2008
Stealth Mode: The first contact Earlham College had with Anina Estrem was when they received her online application.
RICHMOND, Ind. — Anina Estrem first discovered Earlham College through the College's
Web site. She remembers scanning the front page looking for the link to
the equestrian program. Estrem read the equestrian co-op meeting minutes
and remembers thinking that "this is an unusual way to run a barn," noting
for the first time the consensus decision-making process, a hallmark of
Quaker life at Earlham.
That first virtual impression interested Estrem,
and soon she became one of the growing number of students nationwide
whose first contact with their college or university comes with a computer-generated
college application. Admissions offices often call these students "stealth
applicants."
Traditionally, admissions offices know applicants well before the school
ever receives an application. An admissions counselor often meets prospective
students at a high school visit or connections are made when a student
requests information about the institution. When applications are received,
the admissions office generally already has a good bit of information
on the student on file.
Now in her second year at Earlham, Estrem talks about
her experience as a stealth applicant in very matter-of-fact tones,
but this new trend in college admissions is changing the landscape of
college admissions. "Drop-from-the-sky" applications
are increasing enrollment pools and changing the traditional relationship
between colleges and prospective students. Earlham College has seen its
stealth percentage skyrocket from 17 percent of all applications received
four years ago to 30 percent of the current year's applicants.
The Internet Generation
Earlham Dean of Admissions and Financial Aid Jeff
Rickey views the growth of "stealth" applicants with interest.
Jeff Rickey, dean of admissions and financial aid at Earlham,
has been watching this trend with interest but not concern.
He's
seen Earlham's total applicant pool grow, which is due, in part,
to the fact that the application process has become easier
in recent years.
"This has all come about because of the advent of the Internet," Rickey
says. "Students can do their search and evaluation of colleges anonymously."
That evaluation process may also include scouring
surveys, guidebooks and other institutional research, much
of which is now available online. At Earlham, where President Douglas
C. Bennett has been a national leader in accountability and transparency
in the presentation of data, the College gives its Web site visitors access
to a great deal of data about the institution. This includes
Earlham's Common Data Set, NSSE (National Survey of Student Engagement)
results, the Admitted Student Questionnaire and much more. The College's
Web site also links to U-CAN, the first national consumer information
tool developed by colleges and universities, for more information on Earlham.
Stealth Applicants Have Lower Yield Rate
For the current academic year that began in August, Earlham
College enrolled 301 students from an applicant pool of more than 1,800.
Of those enrolled students, 53 were stealth applicants. And
while the jury is still out on the long-term performance of these students,
Rickey says there is definitely a difference in an early commitment
to the college. This commitment is shown by the yield rate,
the percentage of students who actually enroll after being accepted by
the College. At Earlham, stealth candidates yield 18 percent while the
overall yield is 25 percent.
Earlham Dean Finds
Stealth Applicants Increasing
Stealth applications are on the rise at colleges and universities across the country. Using the National Association of College Admission Counseling e-list to survey colleagues, Earlham College Dean of Admissions and Financial Aid Jeff Rickey gathered the following anecdotal information from his peers. (These percentages have not been reviewed for accuracy, but are listed as submitted by peer institutions.)
| School |
Percentage of Total Applicants
Considered "Stealth" |
| Ohio Wesleyan |
34% |
| Naropa (Colo.) |
33% |
| St. Bonaventure (N.Y.) |
32% |
| Dayton (Ohio) |
31% |
| Earlham |
30% |
| Wooster (Ohio) |
30% |
| Smith (Mass.) |
28% |
| Hendrix (Ark.) |
22% |
| Washington, U. of |
21% |
| St. Olaf (Minn.) |
19% |
| DePauw (Ind.) |
19% |
| Kalamazoo (Mich.) |
19% |
| Albion (Mich.) |
18% |
| Augustana (S.D.) |
18% |
| Reed (Ore.) |
17% |
| Beloit (Wis.) |
17% |
| Hood (Md.) |
17% |
| Kenyon (Ohio) |
16% |
| Dickinson (Pa.) |
15% |
| Hope (Mich.) |
14% |
| Denison (Ohio) |
13% |
A staple of a traditional college choice process
is visiting the campus. Estrem didn't visit Earlham's Richmond, Ind. campus before
accepting its offer. Instead, she says she talked with many people in
her hometown of Newberg, Ore., including her high school guidance counselor
and an Earlham alum living in the area. She also says she "memorized
the Web site" prior to her August arrival on campus.
Stealth candidates have not had personal contacts
with admissions officers, college visits or receptions — contacts
that build a connection between the institution and the student. That
connection is reflected in the yield rate. Rickey says many colleges
include a punitive factor into the evaluation process or a "demonstration
of interest" category, which helps
weed out some students who might not be as committed. Earlham
has not taken that step.
However, adjustments have been made the last few years, as yield, thanks
to stealth applicants, is now more difficult to predict. Rickey says that
to remain fully enrolled, Earlham must now admit a larger number of students.
In addition to more easily accessible data, Rickey says that the Internet
has amped up many aspects of the admissions process in recent years. Tools
such as the Common Application are making it easier for students to more
easily apply to many different colleges. The application is an online
generic form accepted at Earlham and more than 300 colleges and universities
including Harvard, Yale, Kenyon and Miami University to name a few.
E-Applications Mean More Applicants, Generally
Earlham supplements the Common Application with an extra
information form, according to Rickey. He says Earlham now receives about
80 percent of all applications electronically.
The ease of sending Internet applications means that students are generally
submitting more applications. Second-year Earlham student Chelsea Pasmore
is one example. During her college search process, Pasmore submitted a
total of 17 applications at various colleges and universities both near
her hometown of Santa Clara, Calif., and other parts of the country. Pasmore
cites many factors that played into her college search including financial
concerns, college fit for her interests and location.
At Earlham, the percent of students submitting more than seven applications
in their search has grown from 18 percent in 2003 to 27 percent in 2007,
according to the Cooperative Institutional Research Program (CIRP) survey,
and Rickey says his office usually sees at least one student each year
that has submitted more than 20 applications.
To make the search more complicated for Pasmore, she was accepted at
15 of those 17 colleges and universities. At that point, the financial
aid and scholarship questions came into play, and soon, Pasmore was visiting
her top five choices, including Earlham. During this time, she studied
the Web sites of each institution.
"I looked at the Earlham Web site a lot," she
says.
Aside from the application process, many institutions
are trying to increase their web presence and reach by pitching their
schools on sites such as MySpace, Facebook and YouTube, as well as with
blogs and podcasts. Earlham is less inclined to be involved in the social
networking phenomenon. Rickey doesn't feel those sites are appropriate
for interacting with prospective students.
"As far as social networking goes, I don't think they [prospective
students] want someone like me contacting them about Earlham through Facebook," Rickey
says.
While yield rate is lower for stealth applicants, that fact seems to
have little bearing on the experiences of Estrem and Pasmore.
The lack of initial connection with the College has
not hindered Estrem's
growth and commitment to Earlham. Now a history major, Estrem anticipates
a spring semester full of history classes. "The academics are right
where I want to be," she says. She is also actively involved with
the Equestrian co-op and says that many of her friends from home
are envious of the opportunities she has to work with horses.
Pasmore too, is very involved. As a psychology/biology
major, she says, "Academically,
Earlham is really good for me."
A member of the Bonner Scholars program, Pasmore tutors local elementary
students and teaches a cooking class at the Boys and Girls Club. She is
also planning a new program through Hospice to help children who are suffering
the death of a parent.
Web Site Enhances Traditional Processes
Earlham continues to enhance its Web site, include the
recent addition of a high-tech virtual campus tour and will shortly
launch a podcasting program, but despite all that transpires online, Rickey
says that more traditional forms of communication may be more
important than ever. The Earlham admissions office is very careful about
how they "roll
out" information to students.
"We still use a lot of first class mail," he says. "We
don't want to have to retract an offer because someone pushed the
wrong button."
— EC —
Contact:
Mark Blackmon,
director of media relations
765/983-1256 — E-Mail
Mark

|