Open Access News

News from the open access movement


Wednesday, September 22, 2004

More on the NIH OA plan

Publishing for Nothing, Science for Free, DCLnews (the newsletter of the Data Conversion Laboratory), September 21, 2004. An unsigned editorial that lays out both sides but does not take a position. Excerpt: "It isn’t just government committees who are calling for more open-access journals [PS: should be "open-access repositories"]; scientists are too. Twenty-five Nobel Prize winners joined the open-access fray at the end of August, asking the government to make all taxpayer-funded research papers freely available....Those signing the letter included DNA co-discoverer James Watson and former National Institute of Health chief Harold Varmus, a long-time supporter of open-access....Many publishers are concerned that open access is being forced on them by government intervention, which they see as unfair. '[We don’t] oppose open-access publishing, but only its premature and unwarranted imposition through government mandate,' the Association of American Publishers said in a statement. Alan Leshner, chief of the American Association for the Advancement of Science, which publishes Science magazine, takes a slightly different view: 'I think all the problems are workable [for the free access publishing plan]. The question is how to do it so we can still pay our bills.' "