Open Access News

News from the open access movement


Saturday, February 12, 2005

Renting and buying v. the commons

Thinking Out Loud About the Ownership Society, an unsigned blog posting from Outsell Now, February 11, 2005. This excerpt comes after a discussion of renting v. buying digital music: 'It's not just the bandwidth that's changing; it's the nature of content itself. In the case of scientific literature, for example, the idea of a journal article or a book as a permanent, fixed document might soon be obsolete. Such literature is inextricably bound up with the other literature it cites, and the literature citing it. Current knowledge on a topic is dynamic and not confined to a single document; in that environment access to the flow of knowledge is more important than ownership of a document that's just a snapshot of knowledge at a point in time. We've concluded that all parts of the content industry are lined up along a "rent vs. buy" spectrum, but that the concept of owning content is slowly losing ground to other models of access.'

(PS: It's true that new models of access are challenging the ownership model. But it's too tidy to suggest that all content lies somewhere on the rent/buy spectrum. OA content is a true commons that is neither rented nor purchased.)