Open Access News

News from the open access movement


Friday, January 13, 2006

Teaching students that not everything is OA

Marylaine Block, Information Literacy: Food for Thought, January 13, 2006. Good teaching exercises for students who "believe everything they need to know is available for free with a simple Google search -- and, if they don't find it there, that it doesn't exist at all."

Comment. I wholeheartedly endorse these teaching exercises. But I have a two-sided response to the belief that if it isn't online [or free online], then it doesn't exist [or isn't worth reading]. On the one hand, on most topics today it's wishful thinking and may remain so for a long time. Don't let students indulge in it and don't fail to teach them what else exists and how to find it. On the other, we should work on making this belief true tomorrow, not just criticize it for being false today. Don't expect students to overlook the spectacular convenience of free online access to scholarship and information. For research authors as well as research readers, it's better to move peer-reviewed research literature into this basket than to keep blaming students for looking first in the basket closest to them.