Open Access News

News from the open access movement


Monday, January 05, 2009

Another legal impediment to book scanning

Peter Hirtle, When is a published work not a publication? Library Law Blog, January 4, 2009.  Excerpt:

...As I discuss in footnote 12 of the copyright duration chart...a ruling in the Twin Books v Walt Disney case in the 9th Circuit (covering the western states) contradicts what everyone else assumes.  In Twin Books, the court concluded that if a foreign work did not follow the requirements to secure copyright protection in the US, the work did not therefore enter the public domain in the US, but instead remained in effect unpublished for the purposes of US copyright law....

[A recent case, Societe Civile Succession Richard Guino v Renoir, criticized Twin Books without overturning it.]

The decision makes it much, much harder to determine whether a book published abroad is in the public domain....